Guidelines for the use of spatially-varying coefficients in species distribution models

01/13/2023
by   Jeffrey W. Doser, et al.
0

Species distribution models (SDMs) are increasingly applied across macroscales. However, assumptions of stationarity in species-environment relationships or population trends inherent to most SDM techniques are frequently violated at broad spatial scales. Bayesian spatially-varying coefficient (SVC) models can readily account for nonstationarity, yet their use is relatively scarce, due, in part, to a gap in understanding both the data requirements needed to fit SVC SDMs, as well as the inferential benefits of applying a more complex modeling framework. Using simulations, we present guidelines and recommendations for fitting single-season and multi-season SVC SDMs. We display the inferential benefits of SVC SDMs using an empirical case study assessing spatially-varying trends of 51 forest birds in the eastern US from 2000-2019. We provide user-friendly and computationally efficient software to fit SVC SDMs in the spOccupancy R package. While all datasets are unique, we recommend a minimum sample size of ∼500 spatial locations when fitting single-season SVC SDMs, while for multi-season SVC SDMs, ∼100 sites is adequate for even moderate amounts of temporal replication. Within our case study, we found 88 spatially-varying occurrence trends. We suggest five guidelines: (1) only fit single-season SVC SDMs with more than ∼500 sites; (2) consider using informative priors on spatial parameters to improve spatial process estimates; (3) use data from multiple seasons if available; (4) use model selection to compare SVC SDMs with simpler alternatives; and (5) develop simulations to assess the reliability of inferences. These guidelines provide a comprehensive foundation for using SVC SDMs to evaluate the presence and impact of nonstationary environmental factors that drive species distributions at macroscales.

READ FULL TEXT

Please sign up or login with your details

Forgot password? Click here to reset