Impacts of Differential Privacy on Fostering more Racially and Ethnically Diverse Elementary Schools
share
In the face of increasingly severe privacy threats in the era of data and AI, the US Census Bureau has recently adopted differential privacy, the de facto standard of privacy protection for the 2020 Census release. Enforcing differential privacy involves adding carefully calibrated random noise to sensitive demographic information prior to its release. This change has the potential to impact policy decisions like political redistricting and other high-stakes practices, partly because tremendous federal funds and resources are allocated according to datasets (like Census data) released by the US government. One under-explored yet important application of such data is the redrawing of school attendance boundaries to foster less demographically segregated schools. In this study, we ask: how differential privacy might impact diversity-promoting boundaries in terms of resulting levels of segregation, student travel times, and school switching requirements? Simulating alternative boundaries using differentially-private student counts across 67 Georgia districts, we find that increasing data privacy requirements decreases the extent to which alternative boundaries might reduce segregation and foster more diverse and integrated schools, largely by reducing the number of students who would switch schools under boundary changes. Impacts on travel times are minimal. These findings point to a privacy-diversity tradeoff local educational policymakers may face in forthcoming years, particularly as computational methods are increasingly poised to facilitate attendance boundary redrawings in the pursuit of less segregated schools.
READ FULL TEXT