On the Stability of General Bayesian Inference
share
We study the stability of posterior predictive inferences to the specification of the likelihood model and perturbations of the data generating process. In modern big data analyses, the decision-maker may elicit useful broad structural judgements but a level of interpolation is required to arrive at a likelihood model. One model, often a computationally convenient canonical form, is chosen, when many alternatives would have been equally consistent with the elicited judgements. Equally, observational datasets often contain unforeseen heterogeneities and recording errors. Acknowledging such imprecisions, a faithful Bayesian analysis should be stable across reasonable equivalence classes for these inputs. We show that traditional Bayesian updating provides stability across a very strict class of likelihood models and DGPs, while a generalised Bayesian alternative using the beta-divergence loss function is shown to be stable across practical and interpretable neighbourhoods. We illustrate this in linear regression, binary classification, and mixture modelling examples, showing that stable updating does not compromise the ability to learn about the DGP. These stability results provide a compelling justification for using generalised Bayes to facilitate inference under simplified canonical models.
READ FULL TEXT